What would you like to find?
Fax (913) 361-0000
7381 West 133rd Street, Suite 401, Overland Park, KS 66213
Board-Certified Psychiatrist

Why Standard TMS Doesn’t Work for Everyone: The Depth Problem

Deep TMS solutions Kansas City
About 30-40% of people who complete a full standard TMS protocol don’t experience meaningful improvement in their depression or anxiety symptoms. For years, this non-response was viewed as treatment failure—but recent research reveals that many of these individuals weren’t failing to respond to brain stimulation. The problem was that the figure-8 coil used in standard TMS couldn’t reach the deeper brain structures where their symptoms originated, which is why Deep TMS with H-coil technology offers a different approach for people whose neural dysfunction lies beyond standard TMS’s shallow reach. For a broader look at how the two technologies compare, see our earlier post on how Deep TMS targets the brain differently than traditional TMS.

The Physics of Magnetic Penetration

All TMS devices create magnetic fields that pass through your skull and induce electrical currents in brain tissue, but the coil design determines how deep those currents penetrate and which brain regions receive therapeutic stimulation. The figure-8 coil, used in standard rTMS devices like Neurostar and Magventure systems, produces a highly focused magnetic field that delivers concentrated stimulation to the outer surface of your cortex—approximately 1-2 centimeters below the skull.

This shallow penetration works well for many depression patients because the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, a primary target for depression treatment, sits near the brain’s surface. The figure-8 coil can effectively stimulate this region, creating the neuroplastic changes that reduce depressive symptoms for people whose mood dysregulation involves these superficial cortical areas. But not everyone’s depression follows this pattern.

Deep brain structures play critical roles in treatment-resistant conditions. The anterior cingulate cortex, buried 4-5 centimeters below your skull, regulates emotional responses and error monitoring. The medial prefrontal cortex, also deep within your brain, connects to limbic regions involved in mood and anxiety. When treatment-resistant depression or OCD involves dysfunction in these deeper structures, standard TMS faces a fundamental limitation—the magnetic field strength dissipates significantly before reaching therapeutic levels at those depths (Zangen et al., 2015).

The H-coil used in BrainsWay Deep TMS was specifically engineered to solve this penetration problem. Instead of the figure-8 configuration that creates focal surface stimulation, the H-coil wraps around larger portions of your head and produces a broader, deeper magnetic field. Computational modeling shows that H-coil stimulation reaches 4-6 centimeters into the brain, maintaining therapeutic current density in the anterior cingulate cortex, medial prefrontal regions, and other structures that remain largely unstimulated by conventional coils (Deng et al., 2014).

Why Depth Matters for Treatment-Resistant Conditions

Standard TMS works remarkably well for a specific subset of depression—cases where the primary neural dysfunction involves dorsolateral prefrontal cortex hypoactivity. For these patients, surface stimulation is sufficient because the affected brain region sits within the figure-8 coil’s effective range. However, treatment-resistant depression often involves more complex circuit dysfunction that extends into deeper brain structures.

The anterior cingulate cortex connects your emotional processing systems to your cognitive control networks. When this region shows abnormal activity patterns, you experience the combination of intense emotional suffering and inability to regulate those emotions that characterizes severe depression. Standard TMS can’t effectively modulate anterior cingulate activity because the coil’s magnetic field has weakened substantially by the time it reaches this depth. You receive treatment, complete all the sessions, but the brain region driving your symptoms never receives adequate stimulation.

OCD demonstrates this depth problem even more dramatically. The neural circuits underlying obsessive-compulsive symptoms involve the medial prefrontal cortex, anterior cingulate cortex, and orbitofrontal cortex—all structures buried deep within your brain. Research shows that these regions exhibit hyperactivity in OCD, creating the intrusive thoughts and compulsive urges that define the disorder. Standard TMS with a figure-8 coil simply cannot reach these structures with sufficient field strength to create therapeutic effects (Rossi et al., 2021).

This explains why the FDA has cleared Deep TMS with the H-coil for OCD treatment, but standard TMS devices don’t have OCD clearance. It’s not a regulatory technicality—it reflects the fundamental physics of magnetic penetration. BrainsWay conducted clinical trials showing that their H-coil could stimulate the medial prefrontal cortex and anterior cingulate cortex effectively enough to reduce OCD symptoms. Standard TMS manufacturers haven’t pursued OCD clearance because their figure-8 coils can’t reliably reach the relevant brain targets.

Individual Brain Anatomy and Treatment Response

Even among people with similar diagnoses, brain anatomy varies significantly. Your cortical thickness, the depth of sulci (the valleys in your brain’s surface), and the distance between your skull and specific brain structures all differ from other patients. These anatomical variations affect how well any given TMS coil can stimulate your particular brain regions.

Standard TMS works best for people whose target brain regions sit relatively close to the skull surface and have favorable sulcal patterns that allow magnetic field penetration. If your dorsolateral prefrontal cortex is deeper than average, or if your cortical folding patterns create physical barriers to magnetic penetration, standard TMS may not deliver adequate current density to the target region even when the coil is optimally positioned. You’re not failing treatment—the treatment physically cannot reach your brain structures effectively.

Computational modeling research demonstrates that H-coil electric field distribution compensates for much of this anatomical variation. The broader, deeper field pattern means that even people with unfavorable anatomy for standard TMS receive therapeutic stimulation in deeper cortical and subcortical regions (Deng et al., 2014). This doesn’t guarantee response—many factors beyond anatomy affect treatment outcomes—but it ensures that the magnetic field actually reaches your relevant brain structures with therapeutic intensity.

Our clinic’s experience treating over 1,000 TMS patients in Kansas City includes many individuals who didn’t respond to standard TMS but achieved meaningful improvement with Deep TMS. This pattern isn’t uncommon—some people’s neural dysfunction simply lies too deep for figure-8 coil technology to address effectively. The H-coil’s additional penetration depth creates treatment possibilities that don’t exist with conventional TMS systems.

The Trade-off Between Focality and Depth

TMS technology involves an inherent trade-off between stimulation focality and penetration depth. The figure-8 coil’s focused magnetic field allows precise targeting of small cortical regions but achieves this precision at the cost of depth. The H-coil’s broader field stimulates larger brain volumes including deep structures, but with less focal specificity than figure-8 designs.

For many clinical applications, this trade-off favors Deep TMS. Treatment-resistant depression and OCD involve circuit-level dysfunction affecting multiple interconnected brain regions rather than isolated problems in single cortical areas. The H-coil’s ability to simultaneously stimulate the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, anterior cingulate cortex, and medial prefrontal regions addresses these distributed circuit abnormalities more comprehensively than figure-8 coils that only reach surface structures.

Some clinicians initially worried that less focal stimulation might cause more side effects by activating brain regions that shouldn’t receive stimulation. However, clinical trials show similar safety profiles between standard and Deep TMS. The broader field doesn’t appear to create problematic activation of unintended brain areas, and the FDA clearance process confirmed that H-coil stimulation meets safety standards for both depression and OCD treatment.

What This Means If Standard TMS Didn’t Work for You

If you completed a full standard TMS protocol without adequate symptom improvement, the depth limitation might explain your non-response. This doesn’t mean you’re untreatable with brain stimulation—it means the specific technology you received couldn’t access the brain structures involved in your condition. Deep TMS represents a genuinely different intervention rather than just a different brand of the same treatment.

Research hasn’t definitively established what percentage of standard TMS non-responders achieve success with Deep TMS, but clinical experience suggests meaningful overlap. People whose depression involves deeper circuit dysfunction that standard TMS couldn’t address sometimes respond when H-coil stimulation reaches those previously inaccessible regions. Results vary by individual, and non-response to one form of TMS doesn’t guarantee response to another—but the technology difference creates legitimate reason to consider Deep TMS after standard TMS failure.

The inverse also occurs—some people respond to standard TMS but might not have responded to Deep TMS if they’d tried it first. The broader field and different stimulation pattern of the H-coil create distinct neural effects compared to focused figure-8 stimulation. There’s no hierarchy of superiority between the technologies—they’re different tools suited to different clinical situations based on where each patient’s neural dysfunction exists anatomically.

Kansas City has one provider offering Deep TMS with BrainsWay H-coil technology. Our clinic serves patients throughout the metro area, including those who travel from Missouri locations for access to this technology. The distinction between standard and Deep TMS matters enough that some people find the additional travel time worthwhile when their symptoms involve deeper brain structures that figure-8 coils can’t effectively reach.

Making Informed Treatment Decisions

Understanding the depth limitation helps you make more informed decisions about TMS options. If you’re considering brain stimulation for the first time, asking whether you’re receiving standard or Deep TMS identifies a fundamental technology difference that affects which brain regions can be treated. If you’ve already tried standard TMS without success, knowing about the depth limitation explains why Deep TMS might offer different results despite both being “TMS.”

This information shouldn’t make you distrust standard TMS—it works very well for many people and represents a valuable treatment for depression. But it should prevent you from assuming all TMS is identical or concluding that brain stimulation can’t help you just because one technology didn’t work. The physics of magnetic penetration creates real differences in which patients respond to which devices.

Results vary by individual, and Deep TMS doesn’t work for everyone. However, for people with treatment-resistant conditions involving deeper brain circuits, the H-coil’s additional penetration depth represents a meaningful clinical advance over figure-8 coil limitations. The technology addresses a specific problem—inadequate stimulation of deep structures—that affects a substantial subset of standard TMS non-responders.

FAQ Section

Q: If I didn’t respond to standard TMS, should I try Deep TMS?
A: It’s worth discussing with your psychiatrist. Some people who don’t respond to standard TMS achieve improvement with Deep TMS because the H-coil reaches deeper brain structures involved in their symptoms. However, non-response to one form of TMS doesn’t guarantee response to another—results vary by individual and depend on many factors beyond coil depth.

Q: Is Deep TMS more powerful than standard TMS?
A: “Powerful” isn’t the right framework—they’re different technologies optimized for different brain regions. Standard TMS delivers more focused surface stimulation, while Deep TMS provides broader, deeper field penetration. Neither is universally superior; the appropriate choice depends on which brain structures need stimulation for your specific condition.

Q: Why don’t all TMS providers use Deep TMS if it reaches deeper?
A: Not all conditions require deep stimulation. Standard TMS works very well for many depression patients whose neural dysfunction involves surface cortical regions. The devices are expensive, require different training, and have different FDA clearances. Many providers successfully treat patients with standard TMS and don’t need Deep TMS technology for their patient population.

Q: Can Deep TMS treat conditions that standard TMS can’t?
A: Deep TMS has FDA clearance for both depression and OCD, while standard TMS only has clearance for depression. This reflects the H-coil’s ability to reach deeper structures involved in OCD pathophysiology that figure-8 coils can’t effectively stimulate. For other conditions, both technologies are used off-label with varying levels of research support.

Q: How do I know if my depression involves deep brain structures that need Deep TMS?
A: Your psychiatrist evaluates multiple factors including symptom pattern, treatment history, comorbid conditions, and response to previous interventions. Treatment-resistant depression, OCD features, and failure to respond to standard TMS suggest possible deep circuit dysfunction where Deep TMS might offer advantages, but individual assessment is necessary.

Exploring Your Options

Standard TMS’s depth limitation creates a subset of non-responders whose neural dysfunction lies beyond the figure-8 coil’s effective reach. This physical constraint doesn’t reflect treatment failure—it reflects technology limitations that Deep TMS was specifically designed to address. Understanding this distinction helps you make informed decisions about whether pursuing H-coil treatment makes sense after standard TMS non-response.

If treatment-resistant depression or OCD has continued despite multiple interventions including standard TMS, the depth problem might explain why previous brain stimulation didn’t work. Learn how Deep TMS with H-coil technology might work when standard TMS hasn’t—contact our clinic in Overland Park or call us at (913) 346-0000 to discuss your treatment history and explore whether Deep TMS is appropriate for your situation.

References

Deng, Z. D., Lisanby, S. H., & Peterchev, A. V. (2014). Coil design considerations for deep transcranial magnetic stimulation. Clinical Neurophysiology, 125(6), 1202-1212. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24411523/

Rossi, S., Antal, A., Bestmann, S., Bikson, M., Brewer, C., Brockmöller, J., Carpenter, L. L., Cincotta, M., Chen, R., Daskalakis, J. D., Di Lazzaro, V., Fox, M. D., George, M. S., Gilbert, D., Kimiskidis, V. K., Koch, G., Ilmoniemi, R. J., Lefaucheur, J. P., Leocani, L., … Hallett, M. (2021). Safety and recommendations for TMS use in healthy subjects and patient populations, with updates on training, ethical and regulatory issues: Expert guidelines. Clinical Neurophysiology, 132(1), 269-306. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33243615/

Zangen, A., Roth, Y., Voller, B., & Hallett, M. (2005). Transcranial magnetic stimulation of deep brain regions: Evidence for efficacy of the H-coil. Clinical Neurophysiology, 116(4), 775-779. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15792886/

Request Your Consultation Today

Are you ready to get back to being the old you? Do you miss doing the things love the most with those you care about the most? Contact our experts today and learn how we can help you take back control of life.

CALL NOW
CONTACT US